PC120 Category 2 response

SMBA - Suggested points for your Category 2 response

If you have received a Category 2 “out of scope” notice from the Independent Hearings Panel Secretariat and wish to respond, SMBA  has provided the following points to help you prepare your response.

The deadline for Category 2 responses is 12 noon Thursday 15 October 2026.

You do not need to use all of the points below. Please use only those that are relevant to your own submission and, wherever possible, put them into your own words.

Start by identifying yourself

You may wish to begin with:

  • My name is [name].
  • I am a resident of St Mary’s Bay.
  • My original PC120 submission number is [number].
  • I was invited to submit on PC120 and spent considerable time reviewing the notified provisions and preparing my submission.
  • I have now received a notice advising that part of my submission has been identified by Council as being “out of scope”.

Explain why you are concerned

You may wish to say:

  • I do not understand why the part of my submission relating to infrastructure capacity in St Mary’s Bay has been identified as “out of scope”.
  • I have not been given a clear explanation of why this part of my submission has been categorised in this way.
  • This makes it difficult for me to understand Council’s position and to properly advise the Independent Hearings Panel why I disagree with that determination.
  • Infrastructure capacity was an important reason for my original submission and remains a significant concern for me.

Points you may wish to raise about infrastructure

SMBA suggests that, where relevant to your original submission, you may wish to refer to the following:

  • The combined wastewater/stormwater system serving St Mary’s Bay is a Qualifying Matter.
  • The National Policy Statement on Urban Development at Part 3.4 expressly states that plan-enabled intensification must be infrastructure-ready.  St Mary’s Bay is not.  It cannot cope at present with heavy rainfall events without causing public health risks to residents.
  • You are concerned that St Mary’s Bay is not currently infrastructure-ready for the level of intensification proposed.
  • You believe infrastructure capacity and readiness should be capable of being considered when deciding whether intensification of this scale is appropriate in St Mary’s Bay.
  • You therefore believe the infrastructure-related parts of your submission should remain within the scope of the PC120 process.

You may also wish to explain the impact on you as a submitter

For example:

  • I found the PC120 submission process complex and spent considerable time preparing my submission in good faith.
  • I am concerned that excluding these points would prevent me from participating fully in decisions about the final form of PC120.
  • I do not believe issues as fundamental as infrastructure capacity should be excluded from consideration without clear reasons being provided.
  • I ask the Independent Hearings Panel to determine that the relevant parts of my submission are within scope.
  • I would like the opportunity to continue participating in the PC120 process and, where appropriate, to be heard by the Panel.

Other Category 2 points

If other parts of your submission have also been identified in Category 2, you may wish to explain why you believe those matters should also remain within scope.

The key question to answer in your own words is:

Why was this issue important enough for you to include in your original submission, and why do you believe the Independent Hearings Panel should still be able to consider it?

Where to send your response

Email your response to:

PC120hearings@aucklandcouncil.govt.nz

Please include your name and original 2025 submission number.

SMBA would also appreciate it if you could BCC stmarysbayassociation@gmail.com so we can understand how many St Mary’s Bay residents are responding and assist our legal and planning advisers in coordinating the Association’s response.

Deadline: 12 noon Thursday 15 October 2026